A response from the Trustees of the British Association for Local History to the Ministry of Justice consultation on the ‘Storage and retention of original will documents’.
Published: 21st February 2024
The British Association for Local History (BALH) is the national charity which promotes local history and serves local historians. BALH has been named as an organisation whose views are sought on this issue. Our interest in this consultation relates to the importance of wills as historical documents, their centrality to understanding people, communities, social networks, material culture and place and place making in the past, and the importance and relevance of history and the original sources which underpin it to ordinary people across this country and around the world.
In essence, BALH finds this proposal to be very much against not only the interests of historians but also the wider, historically interested, public. We understand this consultation document to be primarily aimed at the legal profession and concerned with short-term access relating to the contestation of wills, with the requirements of the public, historians and other interested parties an apparent afterthought. From our experience of working with original documents specifically, and of digitised documents generally, we believe these proposed changes are unlikely to deliver safe and efficient long-term storage, or reduced costs, and may compromise access in the medium to long term. The proposal is ill-informed, lacks substance to support its arguments and is, at points, misleading. To take three examples. Firstly, there are numerous other instances of the mass preservation of documents, most strikingly pre-1858 wills, with which there is not an informed comparison. Secondly, the desired economic benefit, cited as the main reason for this change, is not properly explored in the document, which also lacks proper costing. And, thirdly, while the executive summary notes a possible environmental benefit, the main body of the proposal has no mention of environmental concerns around digitisation and digital preservation, while there is in fact a net environmental cost to digitisation and storage.
We ask the Ministry of Justice, as temporary custodians of these documents, to consider the enduring benefit of preserving the originals to ensure legal accountability and access for the public and historians of all levels of interest and experience long into the future. The principle of mass digitisation (and, therefore, of creating digital surrogates for access in order to reduce handling of original paper records) is one we firmly support, but emphasise that this must be alongside long-term, professional archival preservation and the opportunity to consult the original documents. Digital copies are not directly equitable substitutes and also carry a risk of loss. For the wider present-day public, this proposed cost-saving exercise in the interests of taxpayers is not clearly evidenced in the consultation, but in our view there is minimal likely benefit. We question whether the proposed changes, and the process to enact them, would be the best use of government time and resources. It would also compromise the capacity of individuals and communities to experience the power of original records and the intellectual, sensory and emotional impacts that can have.
Question 1: Should the current law providing for the inspection of wills be preserved?
This needs further definition: does it refer to the content of the will (i.e. digitised copy), the registered will, or the original will. Access to all three versions is vital. The law should provide for the possibility of inspecting the content of the will digitally, with the original documents being retained for instances where the digital copy is insufficient, or in the event of digital failure.
If the imperative here is to reduce costs, there are ways to achieve this compared with the current system that do not involve the disposal of the original wills. Section 124 of the Senior Courts Act 1981, as detailed in the consultation document, does not stipulate where the documents should be retained. Keeping the laws as they stand, but using an alternative storage provider and alternative business model (e.g. longer timescales for completion of enquiries) would almost certainly provide a cheaper alternative to the current position, without the need to dispose of the paper wills.
The current law providing for the inspection of wills need not be preserved in its current form. However, these documents should be deemed archives worthy of permanent preservation, on the same basis as the pre-1858 Prerogative Court of Canterbury, Prerogative and Exchequer Court of York wills and wills in numerous other archives. These wills would therefore probably be best placed with The National Archives at Kew, or another suitable accredited archives service.
Question 2: Are there any reforms you would suggest to the current law enabling wills to be inspected?
The rationale for public inspection of wills does not include the use of these records by historians. Any amendment to legislation should specifically include all members for the public as those for whom inspection should be a right.
Some consideration should be made to the personal data within the wills, particularly where wills were made some time ago and only recently proved, as they may contain personal information relating to living beneficiaries, family members or executors. Any new reforms would have to work in conjunction with the Data Protection Act 2018.
The current laws and procedures outlined above only relate to the life of wills when they are in the hands of the Courts and Tribunals Service. As detailed above, we feel that the procedure should be changed, with these documents being transferred to the care of The National Archives at the end of their retention period (and a suitable retention period imposed in line with other government documents, e.g. 20 years). This would then allow for updated legislation on the inspection of wills.
The current provider is not the only provider of services such as those required by HM Courts and Tribunals Service. Therefore, if transfer to The National Archives is not possible for any reason, alternative options for storage should be considered through a tendering process before destruction is considered.
We feel that an Impact Assessment should be created before this goes any further, as there may well be impacts on organisations at a local level.
Question 3: Are there any reasons why the High Court should store original paper will documents on a permanent basis, as opposed to just retaining a digitised copy of that material?
Wills are a primary source for nearly all historians, whether at a national or local level. As the British Association for Local History we would emphasise the importance of local history for the mental wellbeing of individuals and communities who gain so much value from the study of their history. The tangibility of original records and the emotional and sensory impact of accessing original documents, and the stories they reveal of an individual or community’s past, cannot and should not be compromised by destruction. Therefore, any loss of such documents would be a loss to the study of the past and its wider social benefits.
There is a difference here between retention of the documents by the High Court, and the destruction of those records. There is no reason why the High Court should store original paper wills on a permanent basis, but that does not mean they should be destroyed upon digitisation. For research purposes it would be useful to have the wills both digitised and available to consult in hard-copy, if the digitised version should prove insufficient for any reason - as noted later. It may well be more cost-effective to work with a third party provider or transfer the records to The National Archives directly for permanent preservation, in the same way as pre-1858 wills and administrations, which have survived in their original formats since the medieval period. This would also follow a similar pattern to Quarter Sessions and Magistrates Court records.
Digitising the resources and destroying the originals is not much cheaper than the current position, and no costs have been included in this proposal to show the savings that could be made by digitisation. Mass digitisation requires financial and human resources to carry out, and there is a cost to store images of the quality needed to replace these originals. There is also a wider question of whether, in financing digitisation, the public will be asked to subscribe to an online commercial partner to access these records. Similarly, there is an environmental impact to digital storage, including the ongoing emissions from data systems infrastructure. Digitisation is therefore not in and of itself a more sustainable solution. Before this consultation is progressed further, more details ought to be provided on the third-party supplier, the digitisation standards to be employed, and the standards of transcription to aid access to the documents, as well as any costs to the end user.
We agree with the statement in Point 26 that ‘an indiscriminate system, built on permanent storage of paper records, is inconsistent with the efficiency and economic needs of the objectives of the justice system and this reform programme’. It runs contrary to archival theory relating to the continuum of the record. However this does not mean that these unique archival documents should be destroyed as the original wills have been selected for permanent preservation.
There is no doubt that digital records can have the same legal admissibility as paper records. However, that does not necessitate an economic argument against the storage of paper records. The experience of historians with digitised documents shows that when the digital copy is insufficient due to technical or human error, then sight of the original paper document is essential. The proposed system would place a very high burden on the quality of scanning (and likewise on the quality, expense and scale of digital preservation required). Many digitisation companies aim for about 95% accuracy in photography, and considerably less than that for the creation of indexes and metadata. There will need to be a lot of work, and cost, to ensure all images meet BS10008, with no mis-scans, security issues or missing pages which might undermine the system. In this respect it may be that keeping the original documents is cheaper than digitisation. We only need to look at the business recovery costs being incurred by the British Library following the recent cyber-attack to see how much holding digitised material can cost (and at least they still retain original documents where things have been digitised).
To the British Library’s experience can be added numerous instances of documents digitised in the twentieth century which are no longer accessible because of technical obsolescence and format redundancy etc. Retaining the original documents is the only way of ensuring their safekeeping in the event of a digital malfunction. There can never be a guarantee that digital records will be available for ever as they always rest on physical systems in the finite world.
Although steps are being taken to ensure that platforms for born-digital records will be updated regularly there is no mention of this in the proposal, which is shortsighted. Some of these documents are already over 160 years old. Humanity possesses many hundreds of years’ experience in preserving paper. The experience of preserving digital copies is only a few decades old and has largely proven that the platforms for digital records or databases are outdated quickly.
The statement about incurring additional costs when changing providers would only apply to a single move from the current provider to another. Deepstore, as one example, is a secure underground provider of heritage storage services already used by The National Archives and other archive services for long-term preservation of original documents.
Point 30 argues ‘that the emotional value of such original documents to relatives and to society is likely to diminish over time’. We would argue that this is wholly and palpably untrue. The family and local history sectors are still increasing in popularity, and part of the attraction of this type of research is coming face to face with ancestors and local residents, through the original paperwork they left behind.
History has a strong resonance across much of the British public, as evidenced by the number of television programmes, books, magazines, radio programmes etc. currently being produced. BALH’s own membership consists of tens of thousands of active local historians who we are representing here. We believe our membership and the wider historically interested public find the destruction of such key sources unacceptable.
Elements of the UK administration have developed an unfortunate track record of mismanaging both paper documents and digital source material. For example, the Windrush generation papers and Covid-19 communications. Substantial destruction of this material, especially in the event of any subsequent digital loss, could add to further public mistrust of governmental record-keeping ability.
Question 4: Do you agree that after a certain time original paper documents (from 1858 onwards) may be destroyed (other than for famous individuals)? Are there any alternatives, involving the public or private sector, you can suggest to their being destroyed?
We do not agree that original paper documents should be destroyed. A digital copy can never replace the original. It can be a welcome substitute on many occasions, but not all. Moreover, digitisation carries its own issues of reliability, cost and environmental impact.
As outlined above, the alternative would be to transfer these records to The National Archives, or another suitable archives service, as historically unique and significant documents, given they are worthy of permanent preservation. The National Archives, with an increase in their annual budget to compensate for taking the records, could store and make available those records going forward. This is in line with the pre-1858 wills for both York and Canterbury (the former of which are held permanently by The Borthwick Institute for Archives, University of York), as well as collections of pre-1858 wills held in numerous other archives.
If the suggestion immediately above is not followed, a number of other questions should be investigated including: what the proposed digital access platform would be; who would run it; how the provider will ensure the safety of the personal data contained on the platform; what digital repository will be used to store the digital images and metadata; how the platform will be monitored to ensure content doesn’t become corrupted; how content will be migrated between formats by the provider to prevent that content from becoming obsolete; and whether the data will be solely UK held. The government would also need to ensure safeguards against the commercial exploitation of data by third parties such as charges for access.
Question 5: Do you agree that there is equivalence between paper and digital copies of wills so that the ECA 2000 can be used?
There is not an equivalence between digital copies and paper wills. The process of digitisation and storage are fallible, human processes. There will remain a need to look at the paper wills in certain instances, such as where the quality of the digital copy is insufficient. We can certainly envisage a future possibility where the digital format and system have become outdated and re-digitisation from the original documents may be required.
The proposal misleadingly draws a false equivalence here. For example, the terms ‘will’ and ‘will documents’ are used throughout the paper with the prefixes ‘original’ and/or ‘paper’ and ‘digital’ to suggest an equivalence between the two which does not properly exist. The difference between digital copies and the original documents is distinct.
Question 6: Are there any other matters directly related to the retention of digital or paper wills that are not covered by the proposed exercise of the powers in the ECA 2000 that you consider are necessary?
The legislation requires that the relevant Minister may only use these powers where they consider that electronic communications or storage would be ‘no less satisfactory’ than the alternative (in this case preserving paper documents) (sub-section 8(3)), but we are not convinced that this would hold for the long term.
For the benefit of the wellbeing of historians who contribute to our understanding of history and society, these wills should come under the Public Records Act and so be freely and openly available to all for study. The original records should be retained indefinitely, with the benefit of digital copies as the primary access point, but with recourse to the original documents still possible on occasions where the digital copy is insufficient.
Question 7: If the Government pursues preserving permanently only a digital copy of a will document, should it seek to reform the primary legislation by introducing a Bill or do so under the ECA 2000?
No comment.
Question 8: If the Government moves to digital only copies of original will documents, what do you think the retention period for the original paper wills should be? Please give reasons and state what you believe the minimum retention period should be and whether you consider the Government’s suggestion of 25 years to be reasonable.
We would suggest that these documents are treated in the same way as those being generated in government departments, with a 20-year retention period before transfer to The National Archives. Disposal from HM Courts and Tribunals Service does not have to result in the destruction of the original documents.
Question 9: Do you agree with the principle that wills of famous people should be preserved in the original paper form for historic interest?
We disagree with the principle of making such an arbitrary division. To contemplate retaining wills only of ‘famous and historic figures’ shows a lack of understanding of social trends, structural social biases and of historical research. History and its records are about more than just the ‘famous’. From a local history perspective research means the study of all people within communities, and research based on mass statistical analysis can only be carried out with a large dataset.
The proposal provides no reason why wills of ‘famous and historic’ individuals should be treated differently. Contemplating the retention of the paper wills of any such figures shows the Ministry of Justice appreciates that the original documents possess superior value. The implication is that if the digital copy were sufficient there would be no need to retain any wills at all and by extension that if the wills of the ‘famous and historic’ were to be retained, the same would apply for all wills.
Point 51 of the consultation document misconstrues what is held at The National Archives (TNA). TNA does not solely hold records of famous people who died before 1858 - they hold all Prerogative Court of Canterbury wills from before 1858. This collection includes many hundreds of thousands of wills in their original paper format, most of which were compiled by non-famous people.
Question 10: Do you have any initial suggestions on the criteria which should be adopted for identifying famous/historic figures whose original paper will document should be preserved permanently?
We believe it is almost impossible - and dangerous - to create criteria for this. Some individuals are famous at the time of their death and remain so, while some lose fame over time. Other figures only come to prominence long after their death. Some people are famous at a national level while others are famous locally or within a specific field.
Popular and scholarly conceptions of ‘fame’ change over time, and indeed historians are working all the time to bring new figures to prominence.
Any criteria set now would be open to the bias (unconscious or otherwise) of those of us in the present day, privileging some kinds of people, obscuring others. It is these kinds of biases that many historians have to counter in their work. Not having the original documents would hamper this historical research in the first place and would mean that the opportunity to retain original documents under these proposals would be missed. An example of this would be Florence Nightingale and Mary Seacole, the latter of whom was only brought to prominence in recent decades. To judge by today’s standards would be doing historians, the wider public and future generations a great disservice.
Question 11: Do you agree that the Probate Registries should only permanently retain wills and codicils from the documents submitted in support of a probate application? Please explain, if setting out the case for retention of any other documents.
There may be room to reduce the list of permanently retained documents in the future. However, this is not something that can be applied retrospectively, given the changing nature of how certain types of documents may have been used.
Question 12: Do you agree that we have correctly identified the range and extent of the equalities impacts under each of these proposals set out in this consultation? Please give reasons and supply evidence of further equalities impacts as appropriate.
No comment.
